United Kingdom
Catalog   /   Office & Stationery   /   Printing & Polygraphy   /   Scanners

Comparison Canon CanoScan LiDE 120 vs HP ScanJet G2710

Add to comparison
Canon CanoScan LiDE 120
HP ScanJet G2710
Canon CanoScan LiDE 120HP ScanJet G2710
from £365.05 
Outdated Product
Compare prices 1
TOP sellers
Product typeflatbedflatbed
FormatA4A4
Max. resolution2400x4800 dpi2400x4800 dpi
Technical specs
Optical elementCISCCD
Max. scan area216x297 mm216x297 mm
Colour depth (int.)48 bit48 bit
Colour depth (ext.)48 bit48 bit
Shades of grey256256
Mono scanning4 ppm
Colour scanning4 ppm
Slide moduleis absentbuilt-in
Data transfer
USB /2.0 Hi-Speed/
USB
General
Power sourceuSB poweredmains powered
Power consumption2.5 W21 W
Dimensions250x370x40 mm287x450x65 mm
Weight1.6 kg3.1 kg
Added to E-Catalogseptember 2014january 2008

Optical element

— CIS, abbreviation for "Contact Image Sensor" — contact image sensor. The simplest type of optical element: it is a line across the entire width of the scanner's working space, on which photocells that read the image and LEDs that provide illumination are located in a row. They are inexpensive and take up little space, which, accordingly, makes the scanners themselves cheaper and smaller. On the other hand, CIS sensors have a shallow depth of field, and even small bumps in the scanned image can be out of focus. However, in general, they are quite suitable for both personal and not too complex professional tasks.

— CCD, short for "Charge-Coupled Device" — a charge-coupled device. A much more complex design than CIS, includes a fluorescent lamp, lens and mirror. CCD scanners are larger, heavier and much more expensive than their counterparts in CIS. On the other hand, this type of optical element provides high-quality colour reproduction and a good depth of field, coping well with complex-shaped media. Therefore, advanced professional scanners are usually equipped with a CCD.

— CMOS. The abbreviation for "Complementary Metal-Oxide-Semiconductor" is a complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor structure (the designation CMOS is also used in Russian). A key feature of CMOS sensors is that they capture the scanned image as a whole, similar to photography (and not...line by line, as in other types of optical elements). In fairness, it should be noted that the "instantaneous" scanning does not give a tangible advantage in speed, because. processing the captured image takes quite a long time. However, this feature is extremely useful in cases where it is difficult to ensure the immobility of the scanned material and/or uniform movement of the optical element relative to this material. Such situations often arise when working with book and handheld scanners (see "Type"), so CMOS elements are most popular in such devices.

Mono scanning

The black and white scanning speed provided by the device. Usually, the maximum processing speed for an A4 sheet is indicated, i.e. speed at the lowest resolution. In fact, the speed is usually lower and depends on both the resolution and the size of the original material. The higher the scanning speed, the more convenient it is to work with the scanner; pay special attention to this parameter if you plan to work with numerous black and white images.

Colour scanning

Colour scanning speed provided by the device. In fact, it depends on the selected resolution, colour depth and original dimensions; the characteristics most often indicate the speed for an A4 sheet at the minimum resolution and colour depth, i.e. maximum possible speed. If you only need to scan one or more sheets from time to time, high speed is not too critical, but for working with a large amount of materials, you should look for fast models.

Slide module

By default, the scanner is designed to work with reflective, i.e. opaque materials (such as paper). The slide module allows you to use the device for processing transparent materials, such as photographic film.

Power source

— From the network. The most common option is to connect to a conventional 230 V power supply. This power supply provides enough power to operate any, even the fastest and most performant scanners. Its disadvantage is, in fact, the need for an electrical network.

— From USB. Powered via USB port — the same through which it connects to the computer. This significantly increases the battery life of the scanner — in particular, it can be used with a laptop in places where there is no access to a 230 V network, which is especially important for portable models (see "Portable Design"). On the other hand, the performance of such devices is usually low, and the power of the USB port is not always enough for power supply (which is especially true when using USB hubs).

— Autonomous. Power supply of the scanner from its own batteries (accumulator or replaceable batteries). Such models are as autonomous as possible, because do not require a power cord to operate, and many of them are able to act as separate devices without being connected to a PC at all. Their disadvantage is the risk of switching off at the most inopportune moment due to the exhaustion of the charge — then you have to either change the batteries (which at least requires fresh ones) or recharge the battery (which takes time).

Power consumption

The maximum power consumed by the scanner during operation. The higher the power, the more energy the scanner consumes, but this only applies to the scanning process itself — in standby mode, power consumption is negligible. And even at the peak in most models, the power is so low that in fact this parameter has practically no effect on electricity bills and is more of an auxiliary value (for example, it is used to calculate the total power of devices connected to an uninterruptible power supply).
Canon CanoScan LiDE 120 often compared