United Kingdom
Catalog   /   Automotive   /   Vehicle Accessories   /   Roof Boxes & Racks

Comparison Thule Motion XT XL vs Thule Ocean 200

Add to comparison
Thule Motion XT XL
Thule Ocean 200
Thule Motion XT XLThule Ocean 200
Compare prices 3Compare prices 1
TOP sellers
Main
Available skis (5 – 7 pcs. up to 200cm) and snowboards (3 – 5 pcs) when installing an adapter (Thule Box Ski Carrier 694-9), which is purchased separately
Typeboxbox
Installationcrossbarscrossbars
Specs
Load capacity75 kg50 kg
Internal capacity500 L450 L
Openingdouble-sidedone-sided
Lock
Materialplasticplastic
External dimensions (LxWxH)215х91.5х44 cm175x82x45 cm
Weight23.5 kg14 kg
Color
Added to E-Catalogapril 2017july 2014

Load capacity

The maximum weight that is allowed to be carried on the boot.

It is definitely not worth exceeding this parameter — even if the structure does not break immediately, this can happen at any time due to off-design loads. And ideally, you should have some margin for carrying capacity — this will give an additional guarantee in case of emergency situations (like hitting a wheel in a hole at speed).

Also note that the weight of the intended load must be supported not only by the boot itself, but also by the crossbars on which it is installed (if this installation option is used, see above). Moreover, the weight of both the cargo and the boot falls on the crossbars, which requires an even greater margin for load for them.

As for specific carrying capacity indicators, in general, the indicator up to 50 kg is considered relatively low, 51 – 75 kg — average, 76 – 100 kg — above average, and in the most "heavy" models, the permissible load weight exceeds 100 kg.

Internal capacity

The internal volume of the closed boot — boxing (see "Type").

Along with the load capacity (see above), this parameter determines the amount of cargo that can be placed in the boot. At the same time, we note that more load-bearing models generally have a more extensive interior space; however, products of a similar "weight category" may differ markedly in this indicator. And here it is worth proceeding from the fact that with the same allowable weight, a more voluminous boot is better suited for light and/or bulky goods, but it will have more weight, dimensions and price, and also (with a high probability) create additional resistance during movement, especially at high speed.

As for specific values, most modern boxes have a capacity in the range of 400 – 500 liters. A volume of 300 – 400 liters or less is considered relatively small, more than 500 liters — large.

Opening

The parameter determines from how many sides the boot is accessed (see "Type"). From a practical point of view, the choice on the opening side depends on who most often needs access to the contents of the boot. For example, it is most convenient for the driver to get the content from the left-side boot – since the steering wheel is usually located on the left, you do not have to go around the car to open the container. For the same reason, the right-side opening will be optimal for the passenger in the front seat. That is why most of the models have a -two-side opening. One-sided boots mostly have an opening on the left. For full versatility, a rear opening is also provided — in boots with a three-side opening. But this is a very rare and not much in demand option.

External dimensions (LxWxH)

Boot dimensions in working position; usually indicated for open models and boxes (see "Type"). The capacity of the product directly depends on this parameter, in particular, its suitability for transporting large items. And in the case of boxes, dimensions also affect aerodynamics: increasing the height or width increases drag and fuel consumption. At the same time, it should be noted that the aerodynamics of the container also largely depends on its shape.

For open boots, the height is most often not indicated — after all, its actual value usually depends not on the dimensions of the structure, but on the size of the cargo being transported.

Weight

Net weight of the boot in working (fully assembled) form.

The light weight contributes to fuel economy (especially during long-term use) and also makes it easier to transport the boot outside the car (for example, from storage to the car and back). On the other hand, lightening the product leads either to a decrease in its strength and load capacity, or to an increase in cost. So in certain situations, a relatively heavy boot may be the best choice; and when choosing a light model, you should pay special attention to the claimed load capacity.
Thule Motion XT XL often compared
Thule Ocean 200 often compared