United Kingdom
Catalog   /   Automotive   /   Car Audio   /   Radar Detectors

Comparison SilverStone F1 Monaco GS vs PlayMe HARD 3

Add to comparison
SilverStone F1 Monaco GS
PlayMe HARD 3
SilverStone F1 Monaco GSPlayMe HARD 3
from $140.35
Outdated Product
Outdated Product
TOP sellers
Main
Confidently picks up signals of all ranges. GPS module. Updated base of stationary cameras. Protection against VG-2. Voice over.
Bands
Bands
K
Ka
Ku
X
K
Ka
 
X
Laser wavelength800 – 1100 nm800 – 1100 nm
Pulse signals
Pulse signals support
 
POP
Ultra-K (K-Pulse)
Instant-On
POP
 
Radar type detection
Radar type detection
Autouragan
Strelka
Robot
Avtodoria
LISD
Krechet
Kris
Arena
Vizir
Кордон, АМАТА
Autouragan
Strelka
Robot
Avtodoria
 
 
Kris
Arena
 
 
Features
Functions
VG-2 protection
false alerts filter
signature technology
Auto mode
Highway mode
City mode /3 modes/
speed limit setting
display brightness adjustment
mute
voice alert
disable bands
VG-2 protection
false alerts filter
signature technology
Auto mode
Highway mode
City mode /3 modes/
speed limit setting
display brightness adjustment
mute
voice alert
disable bands
Receiver
Receiver typesuperheterodynesuperheterodyne
Signal processingdigitaldigital
GPS
General
Current consumption225 mA
Dimensions109x67x26 mm
Weight121 g113 g
Added to E-Catalogfebruary 2019september 2018

Bands

Radio frequency bands detected by a radar detector. Modern radars mainly use radio waves, only relatively recently have models with a laser operating principle appeared (see "Laser Wavelength").

K band (24.05-24.25 GHz). The most popular range of police radars in the CIS countries. Just like X, it is almost mandatory for radar detectors.

Ka band (33.4-36.0 GHz). A relatively new and quite promising range, providing a speed determination range of about 1.5 km with improved accuracy. In common parlance, it is also called "American", because. in Europe, there are practically no police radars on Ka.

Ku band(12-18 GHz). A range found in some Eastern European and Baltic countries. It was widely used in Europe for some time, but is gradually disappearing from the scene due to a frequency conflict with satellite television.

Band X(10.5-10.55 GHz). The first frequency range allocated at one time for speed recording radars (it has been used all over the world since the middle of the last century). Receivers for such radiation are simple and inexpensive, and therefore X-band support is found in almost all modern radar detectors. At the same time, today it is considered obsolete and is not used at all in many countries.

Note that the abundance of supported ranges is not always a virtue. In each of them th...ere is a fairly large amount of interference, leading to false positives — despite the fact that the local police radars of this range may not be used at all. Therefore, before buying, it is worth clarifying which ranges are relevant in your area, and ideally, choose a device with the ability to turn off individual ranges.

Pulse signals support

The types of pulse signals that a radar detector can detect. Modern police radars, usually, do not use a constant exposure mode, but short (fraction of a second) pulses, and even if the detector supports the appropriate range, it does not mean that it will be able to detect a pulsed signal in this range.

Here are the main types of such signals that are relevant for modern radar detectors:

Instant On. Name for the general mode of operation used in most modern police radars. A radar operating in this mode emits radio waves only directly when measuring speed, for a very short period (less than a second).

P.O.P. Mode of operation used primarily in K- and Ka-band radars (see above). Provides a single pulse of extremely short length — about 0.07 s.

Ultra-K (K-Pulse). The standard pulse mode of operation of the radar in the K band. Unlike POP, it provides measurement using several pulses and a longer total measurement duration — up to 0.4 s. Thus, the requirements for detectors under Ultra-K are somewhat softer than under POP, however, for correct recognition, support for this mode must still be claimed directly.

Ultra Ka. The standard pulse mode of the radar in the Ka band. In terms of its main features, it is completely similar to the Ultra-K described above, differing only in operatin...g frequencies.

— Ultra Ku. The standard pulse mode of the radar in the Ku band. In terms of its main features, it is completely similar to the Ultra-K described above, differing only in operating frequencies. It occurs very rarely, due to the gradual exit of the Ku range itself from use (for more details, see "Ranges of operation").

— UltraX. The standard pulse mode of the radar in the X band. Like the X band itself, this mode is considered obsolete and is provided more “just in case” and as a tribute to tradition than for practical reasons.

Radar type detection

Models of police radars that are guaranteed to be able to recognize the detector.

In addition to general characteristics (range, pulse length and configuration, etc.), different radar models may have various specific features that make detection difficult. In addition, manufacturers indicate this parameter for marketing reasons: choosing a radar detector for compatibility with specific radars is easier than delving into the details of ranges and pulse modes.

Here are some of the most popular models of modern police radars:

Autohurricane. An automated system, the main component of which is video cameras — according to the data from them, Avtohuragan can even recognize speed and record violations of the speed limit. The radar itself in the Avtohuragan systems is used optionally, so even if compatibility is claimed for the detector, this is not a guarantee of detection (the complex can work without a radar). Some models may have a database of Autohurricane coordinates and automatic GPS-based warnings (see below), but this is also not perfect.

Arrow. A fairly advanced automated complex with a detection range of about 1 km. It is this complex that is often associated with "letters of happiness" — written notices of violations and fines, which began to be sent to drivers in some countries. "Arrow" can operate at frequencies that differ from the standard, which makes...it difficult to detect by traditional radar detectors; for a guaranteed response to Strelka, such a possibility must be explicitly stated in the characteristics.

— Robot. Automated devices that originally appeared in the EU countries. They are colloquially referred to as "birdhouses" for their characteristic shape and installation mainly on poles. Like the Strelka described above, the Robot radar operates in its own range, which is not related to the standard ones.

— Avtodoriya. An integrated system for obtaining road information, which provides, among other things, speed control. When measuring the speed, the car is fixed by cameras of two sensors — at the beginning and at the end of the control section; the speed of movement is calculated by the time it takes to pass this section, and the video allows you to recognize numbers. The Avtodoria system does not use radars, so the only way to "oppose" it is to use databases with coordinates of control areas. In some detectors, such databases can be automatically updated, including according to data from the marks put on the map by other drivers.

— LISD. Radars operating in the laser range ("laser speed and range metres"), with a wavelength in the range of 800 – 1100 nm. Can be supplemented with photo fixation blocks. Note that for many detectors that are claimed to be compatible with LISD, the recognizable wavelength range may be narrower; therefore, even such devices do not give an absolute guarantee from the laser metre.

— Gyrfalcon. Complex systems (usually stationary) combining a video camera and a K-band radar. Usually, they are mounted on poles or other similar supports, at a height of several metres.

— Chris. A photoradar system including a K-band radar. Usually used from a tripod mounted on the side of the road.

— Arena. A photoradar complex used both stationary and mobile — from a tripod or even from hands. Works in K-band. Installation at a distance of up to 1.5 km from the main post is possible, with data transmission via a wireless channel.

— Vizier. One of the most popular complexes for measuring speed and photographic fixation in the countries of the former USSR. Uses K-band radar.

— Spark. A hand-held radar with a characteristic shape ("hair dryer"), operating in a pulsed mode in the K-band; one of the few models in the CIS that operate in POP mode (see "Support for pulse signals"). The range is about 800 m, but in fact it is limited by the accuracy of pointing the device.

— Falcon. An obsolete X-band handheld radar, discontinued in 2008 but still in service in some countries. Range — up to 600 m.

— Berkut, Radis. Popular hand-held K-band radars, with a range of up to 800 m.

— Binar. A hand-held device that combines a radar with a photofixator for two cameras — wide-angle and "long-range". The radar module operates in the K-band.

— Rapier. Stationary device used both separately and as a component of other systems. Equipped with a camera and a highly focused K-band radar.

— Amata. A laser speed metre with a photofixator, similar to the LISD described above, but surpassing it in "range" (up to 700 m).

Current consumption

The current nominally consumed by the radar detector during operation. Usually, with a regular connection to the cigarette lighter socket with the engine running, this parameter does not play a special role — even the most advanced models do not “eat” so much that this noticeably affects the operation of the on-board network. In fact, current consumption data may be useful only in some specific situations — for example, battery operation.
SilverStone F1 Monaco GS often compared
PlayMe HARD 3 often compared