Comparison Tatonka Alcohol Burner vs Tramp TRG-013

Type of fuel for which the burner is designed.

— Gas. Liquefied gas (usually isobutane or a propane-butane mixture) supplied in special small cylinders that are easy to transport. Gas burners are practical, easy to use, compact (often smaller than the cylinders themselves) and inexpensive, making them extremely popular. Of their noticeable shortcomings, one can only note a decrease in efficiency in the cold and/or in high altitude conditions, however, these moments are not so often critical, and in some models they are compensated by the use of preheating systems.

— Liquid fuel. Liquid fuel, most often alcohol, gasoline or kerosene; however, different models can be designed for different types of fuel, this point should be clarified separately. Anyway, the main advantage of such burners over gas burners is the constant efficiency in almost any conditions, including at low temperatures and high in the mountains. In addition, liquid fuels are somewhat more affordable: for example, gasoline in a pinch can be bought at a gas station or hardware store. On the other hand, liquid fuel models are mostly heavier and more bulky than gas ones, and when using poorly refined fuel, an unpleasant odour appears and the nozzles are likely to become clogged. High-quality fuel is not available everywhere and can be quite expensive. Therefore, there are fewer such models produced than gas ones.

...— Multi -fuel. Multi-fuel burners are those that can operate on both gas and liquid fuels. The delivery set of such a burner, respectively, includes both a connector for a cylinder and a special container for liquid fuel (or at least an adapter with a pump for an external tank); also, when changing the type of fuel in some models, a replacement of the working part is required. Anyway, such a burner allows you to choose the type of fuel depending on the situation; on the other hand, such versatility affects the price, dimensions and weight of the entire device.

— Solid fuel. Burners designed for solid fuel — usually wood in the form of twigs, chips, special pellets, cones, etc. In fact, such a burner is a more advanced and efficient analogue of a conventional campfire. Efficiency is achieved due to the fact that many of these devices have combustion chambers of a special design that ensures complete combustion of fuel (this is unattainable in a conventional fire). And the main advantage of this type of burners over gas or liquid fuel models is that in many cases you don’t need to carry fuel with you — for example, while hiking through the forest, it literally “rolls under your feet”. On the other hand, fuel is not so easily available in every locality; and it takes up noticeably more space in the luggage than a container with gas or liquid. In addition, solid fuel (even in the form of special pellets) is noticeably more difficult to ignite, its combustion power is more difficult to regulate (although possible), and a “muffled” burner with unburned fuel inside can cool down for quite a long time, which sometimes creates inconvenience.

A method of fastening a cylinder or other container with fuel provided in the burner.

— Threaded. Threaded connection — simply put, the cylinder in such models is screwed to the device. It is mainly used in burners and lamps (see "Type") on gas fuel, although there are exceptions. Both the connection itself and the fuel containers designed for it are durable and reliable, which makes this option very popular.

— Collet(it is also choke or stock). A variant used in most stoves (see "Type"), but also found in traditional burners. A cylinder for such a mount has an outlet in the form of a short tube (rod), which, when connected, is fixed in a special clamp — a collet. Installing and removing such cylinders takes less time than threaded ones, and the containers themselves are somewhat cheaper. On the other hand, the collet is somewhat inferior to the thread in terms of reliability.

— Portable. Burners in which the fuel tank is connected not directly, but through a special hose. This design provides a number of advantages. Firstly, the burner installed separately from the cylinder is more stable, and the whole structure is more fireproof, since the fuel supply is quite far from the flame. Secondly, the fuel container can have almost any shape and size — the main thing is that it fits the hose mount. Thirdly, this container can be turned over and/...or raised relative to the burner, increasing the rate of fuel supply; this is especially useful when using gas burners in the cold. On the other hand, such devices, when unfolded, take up more space and have a higher risk of leakage than direct-connected burners.

— Built -in. Fuel tank, made as a single unit with the burner. This option is found only in liquid fuel models (see "Fuel") — it is easier and safer to use removable cylinders for working with gas. An integrated tank is stronger and more reliable than a removable or separate one, it has a minimal risk of leakage; on the other hand, the inability to separate the burner from the tank can create some inconvenience during storage and transportation.

Some models of burners allow the connection of cylinders with a "non-native" mount — through an adapter. However, this option is rather a spare in case of emergency, and it is best to use the standard containers. Also note that the compatibility of a particular cylinder with a burner should be clarified separately, even if it matches the general type of attachment. The fact is that different manufacturers of fasteners of the same type (thread, collet) may differ in characteristics and be incompatible with each other. It is best to use cylinders directly recommended by the manufacturer (see "Replacement cylinders").

The rated power of the burner is the amount of heat generated by it during operation. For models with power control, the value is indicated at the maximum mode.

The nuances of choosing this parameter depend on the type of device. So, the general rule for burners and stoves (see "Type") states that at least 1 kW of power is needed to efficiently heat 1 liter of liquid. And the volumes that you have to deal with depend on the number of tourists and the expected conditions: in a warm climate, 600-700 mL per person is enough for 1 cooking, in a cool one — 1 liter, and it is better to clarify recommendations for different types of extreme tourism in special sources. Thus, the minimum indicator for burners is actually 1 kW, for stoves — 1.5 kW, and the most powerful ones can provide 3 kW or more. Note that more powerful burner models have the appropriate dimensions and weight, and you can heat a large amount of food several times; so for long hikes with luggage carried on you, a relatively low-powered device may be more suitable.

In the case of heaters, it can be assumed that a power of 1 – 1.5 kW is enough for 5 – 7 m2 of area — this is quite enough to heat a tent or tent, higher power is rarely required in fact. And for lamps, the main indicator of efficiency is not power, but luminous flux (see below).

The amount of fuel required for the normal operation of the burner for a certain time; usually stated in grams per hour. Different manufacturers may calculate fuel consumption differently, but most often it is indicated for normal operation, when the burner produces the power indicated in the documentation (see "Power"). Knowing the fuel consumption and the capacity of the cylinder used (see "Replaceable cylinders") or the built-in tank (see "Filling volume"), you can easily calculate the time of continuous operation of the burner.

The time that the burner is able to work without changing the cylinder or refilling the tank. Usually, the characteristics indicate the operating time at maximum power (see above); at lower power, the actual operating time may be longer than stated. However, it is best to evaluate and compare different models by directly claimed battery life.

Another important nuance is that battery life directly depends on the volume of the fuel tank — and many modern burners are designed for interchangeable cylinders produced in different volumes. Therefore, the characteristics may indicate for which cylinder model the continuous operation time is given (and for multi -fuel models, the type of fuel should also be specified). If there are no such data, the tank capacity required for a certain time can be calculated from fuel consumption: for example, gas consumption of 180 g / h and battery life of 120 min (2 h) mean that the data are given for a cylinder of at least 360 g (400 mL) gas. With other volumes, the time of continuous operation will differ accordingly.

The maximum amount of fuel that can be placed in the burner in one refueling. This parameter is relevant mainly for liquid and multi-fuel models (see "Fuel"), it corresponds to the working volume of the tank (complete or built-in). At the same time, a larger tank allows you to work longer without refueling, but it affects the dimensions and weight of the entire structure. Therefore, its volume is chosen depending on the performance in such a way that one filling is enough for at least 1.5 – 2 hours; in lamps and compact heaters (see "Type") the battery life can be much higher.

The ability to adjust the power of the burner. This feature is useful given that working at full capacity is not always justified. For example, a rather weak flame is sufficient to maintain a boil; on high heat, many dishes burn, warm up unevenly, and even the fuel consumption is unreasonably high, etc. Thanks to the power regulator, you can "screw" the burner flame to the desired level — or vice versa, set it to full power, depending on the current need.

Availability in a torch of function of preliminary heating of fuel. In such models, the fuel supply system is designed in such a way that the burner flame slightly heats the fuel line during operation.

This function somewhat complicates the design and increases its cost, but increases efficiency and reduces fuel consumption. The presence of preheating is especially important if the device is planned to be used in the cold and/or in high altitude conditions. Under such conditions, the gas pressure at the outlet of the cylinder drops significantly, and liquid fuel can become viscous; both have a negative effect on power and efficiency, while heating allows you to compensate for these phenomena.

The presence of a cover in the delivery set of the burner. The cover will be useful during transportation and storage: it will protect the device from various negative impacts and reduce the risk of losing components (after all, burners are often stored and transported unassembled). For this purpose, impromptu packaging can also be used, however, a complete case that is optimally suited for the burner will be more reliable and practical. In addition, in models with a cooking container (see above), the cover can also play the role of a heat-insulating casing, which allows you to transfer the device right during the cooking process.